The Public examines the rights and wrongs about access and conflict


There are many reasons that people enter the doors of their favorite public library every day.

The programs. The WiFi. The computers. The magazines. The books, still and even.

The feeling of community.

I see it in the faces and hear it in the voices as I make the rounds for my job in the communications department of the Liverpool Public Library.

Sometimes these diverse goals don’t always match up. The needs of various patrons may not jive. Perhaps some of the rules set down by the library or social mores get in the way.

The Public takes a hard look at one such night at the main branch of one big city library.

Written and directed by Emilio Estevez, the drama takes place one winter in Cincinnati, during a cold spell that’s maxed out the city’s homeless shelters and caused after-hours stress, and, yes, even the death of one of the many homeless patrons who use the downtown main branch and its welcoming services during its open hours.

Estevez also plays Stuart, a sturdy librarian who’s gained the trust of many of these patrons during his regular rounds, as well as the confidence of his co-workers up and down and laterally across the chain. Until the city’s DA, who’s also running for mayor, comes in with the news of a lawsuit from one homeless man who’s named Stuart and the security guard who led him out of the library one day, citing his body odor as the reason for his banishment. The city would prefer to settle. The library chief tells Stuart he’s on rocky ground.

And then a big group of the daily homeless decide that they will not leave the library at closing hours that night to venture out into the bitter cold with no space at any shelters.

United they stand. (From

Stuart is faced with some personal reckoning, and picks their side.

Alec Baldwin rushes in as the lead police negotiator, a man who doesn’t really want to go overboard tough because he has some skin in the game, too.

Christian Slater does well as the villain, the DA who has no problem taking on the Get Em Outta Here role. The Public library can’t cave to this group’s need for a warm place to spend the night or what will some other group ask of from the city next time?!

Other shades of sympathies come from a fellow librarian played well by Jena Malone, the raised-eyebrow security guy played even better by Jacob Vargas, the library director played by Jeffrey Wright and Stuart’s apartment house friend-maybe-more played by Taylor Schilling. Schilling has earned her stripes for a role like this, mind you, from her years as Piper in the Netflix hit Orange Is the New Black.

Estevez satisfyingly plays Stuart as a man who knows what he must do to reconcile the past, present and future.

The homeless men show great pride and reason, too.

9 thoughts on “The Public examines the rights and wrongs about access and conflict

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.